I am disappointed with this product. The surface composition of the pencil is very hard and I must use way too much pressure on my eyelid and lower lash line to apply it. I does not glide on smoothly at all. I will be returning it.

I'd been on the hunt for a great eye pencil that does not have harmful ingredients. I had been using Well People brand but it did not glide on easily and was very frustrating. I prefer eye pencils to liquid liners.
Since I purchase all of my skin care through Natural Beauty Group, I figured why not try Jane Iredale liner. I started with Black Brown, then Brown, and I recently added Basic Black. These are BY FAR the best healthy eye pencils I have ever used. They glide on easily and without putting harmful chemicals on my eyes/skin. Also, if you buy these eye pencils, do yourself a favor and purchase the sharpener.. one of the best $3 I've ever spent. It arrived with the clear part detached but it snapped back on just fine. It's sharpens perfectly (nice fine point). I'm SO pleased.

Tried out the Jane Iredale eye pencil for the first time. It is good because it applies on smoothly and it does not irritate my eyes.

This was my first purchase of this item and I am very happy. Easy to use.

I really like this liner so far. The shade isn't too light, or too dark (color: basic brown). It glides on easily, and stays on all day. I did purchase the Jane Iredale sharpener, but haven't had to use it yet. I wish you had a nude eyeliner. Hint, hint!!!